← Back to all articles

Commercial Loan Restructuring: How It Works and How to Start

Business owner reviewing revised loan terms

Commercial loan restructuring means renegotiating the terms of a business loan you already have, so payments fit your cash flow. Typical changes are a lower rate, a longer term, a temporary payment break or, less often, a reduced balance. It works best when you ask early, with numbers in hand, and before you miss payments. If your debt is a merchant cash advance (MCA), the same idea applies, but the contract and the path look different, and we cover both below.

Key Takeaways

  • Restructuring changes the terms of your existing agreement. Refinancing replaces the loan with a new one, and bankruptcy is a court process.
  • Lenders usually prefer a workable deal to a default, so a well-prepared, early request gives you the best chance of being heard. Nothing is guaranteed.
  • Prepare a short-term cash flow projection, a clear explanation of what went wrong and a plan for the new terms before you call.
  • Restructuring can raise total interest, add collateral or guarantees, and may be reported as a modification, so weigh the full cost.
  • MCA obligations follow different rules from term loans. A no-obligation assessment can show which restructuring routes fit your situation.

Table of Contents

What commercial loan restructuring actually is

Investopedia defines debt restructuring as revising the terms of a debt agreement to improve financial stability and avoid default, and describes it as a less expensive alternative to bankruptcy when a borrower is in financial turmoil.

The key word is existing. NerdWallet explains that restructuring a small-business loan means renegotiating its terms, which changes the current agreement instead of replacing the loan the way refinancing does.

In practice, a lender can:

  • lower the interest rate
  • extend the repayment term
  • forgive a portion of the loan
  • let you sell collateral to reduce what you owe

Those options come from the same NerdWallet guide. A lender may also agree to fee waivers, a temporary forbearance or the release of a lien or guarantor, as Hamilton Merchant describes for out-of-court workouts.

Restructuring, refinancing, settlement and bankruptcy compared

These terms get mixed up, and the difference matters because each one has different costs and consequences. ABF Journal’s overview separates them this way: refinancing is a financing transaction, bankruptcy is a judicial process, a negotiated workout depends on creditor agreement, and settlement aims to resolve an obligation for less than the contractual amount.

Route What happens Who has to agree Court involved
Restructuring or modification Terms of the current loan change Your lender No
Refinancing A new loan pays off the old one A new lender (or the same one) No
Settlement You pay less than the full balance, often after default Your creditor No
Bankruptcy A court supervises discharge or reorganization Court process Yes

If you want a closer look at the refinancing side, this overview of business loan refinancing options shows how a new loan is compared and priced, which helps you judge whether replacing debt beats changing it.

Three kinds of workout

The ICSC’s loan workout materials describe a workout as a lender and borrower resolving a default without the lender exercising its full remedies. They name three types:

  1. Forbearance: you make a reduced payment, or none, for a set time.
  2. Restructuring, amendment or modification: the payment terms or other conditions change permanently.
  3. Waiver: the lender gives up its rights for specific defaults.

A forbearance buys time. A modification changes the deal. Many businesses use a forbearance first and move to a modification once their numbers recover.

Why a lender would say yes

Lenders are not looking for a fight. The ICSC materials note that lenders generally understand that driving a borrower into bankruptcy and litigation is riskier than a workout, and they usually do not want to take over and manage seized property. Their main goal is to maximize what they recover on the loan.

That is the lens for your request. You are not asking for a favor. You are showing that the new terms leave the lender better off than a default would.

Timing matters too. NerdWallet quotes an SBA lending manager who says a restructuring request typically comes as the very last resort before final default or bankruptcy. The lesson is to ask sooner, while your payment history is still clean and your options are widest.

How to ask for a restructuring

FindLaw’s guide to business loan workouts and the ICSC materials point to the same preparation. Here is the sequence.

  1. Diagnose the problem first. Identify what caused the shortfall: a lost customer, a slow season, a cost spike. Name every default, not just the one you expect the lender to raise.
  2. Build a short-term projection. Prepare cash flow projections covering the next three to six months, plus recent financial trends.
  3. Show a workable plan under the new terms. Include concrete steps to raise sales or operating efficiency, and show that the proposed payment is one you can actually make.
  4. Have the paperwork professionally prepared. FindLaw advises using an accountant or auditor to produce the financials, and requesting a workout meeting only when the package is ready.
  5. Contact the lender early and keep talking. The ICSC materials advise communicating early and often.
  6. Write down every agreement. Keep copies of what was proposed, accepted and changed.

A well-presented plan also helps with outside parties. If you are lining up other capital at the same time, a lender-ready guide shows how to frame financials so a financing partner can follow them quickly.

A quick example of the numbers lenders look at

Suppose a business owes $100,000. FinHelp’s worked example shows a loan at 8% over 36 months costs about $3,130 a month and roughly $12,680 in interest. Stretching it to 84 months at 6% drops the payment to about $1,462 a month but raises total interest to about $22,808.

Monthly payments and total interest across loan terms

The lesson applies to restructuring too: a longer term eases the monthly strain and can cost more overall. Know both numbers before you sign.

What restructuring can cost you

A good restructuring solves a cash flow problem. It also has consequences you should price in.

  • More total interest. NerdWallet notes that restructuring may increase what you pay over the life of the loan.
  • Tax on forgiven debt. Forgiven debt could be taxed as ordinary income, though exceptions apply. Ask your accountant before you agree to any reduction in principal.
  • More collateral or guarantees. Lenders may ask for additional collateral or other guarantees. Daeryun Law notes that a restructuring may require the owner’s personal guarantee, which makes the owner jointly liable for the restructured debt.
  • Credit reporting. FinHelp reports that credit bureaus and commercial reporting can label a loan as restructured or modified, which can affect later borrowing terms.

Personal guarantees deserve extra attention. LegalClarity explains that a business bankruptcy alone does not erase an owner’s personal guarantee. To discharge it, the owner must file personal bankruptcy. That is one reason many owners try a negotiated route first.

SBA relief for cash flow trouble

Government programs are narrower than most owners expect, so check eligibility before you plan around them.

For COVID-EIDL borrowers, the SBA’s COVID-era programs page describes a hardship accommodation that cuts payments by 50% for six months through the SBA Loan Portal. The loan must be less than 90 days past due and current, the business must be open and operating, no owner can be in active bankruptcy, and the problem must be a temporary cash flow difficulty. It can be used once every five years, and interest keeps accruing during the reduced-payment period. Check that page for the current rules before you apply.

If you need new capital rather than relief on an old loan, the SBA’s 7(a) program offers loans up to $5 million. Borrowers must be creditworthy, show a reasonable ability to repay and be unable to get the credit on reasonable terms elsewhere. That last test can be hard to meet when you are already stretched.

SBA relief for cash flow trouble

Restructuring a merchant cash advance

An MCA is not a loan in the traditional sense. The funder buys a share of your future receivables and collects through daily or weekly withdrawals. That is why term-loan advice does not map neatly onto it, and why payments can feel heavy when sales dip.

Common paths for an MCA include:

  • Reconciliation: asking the funder to adjust withdrawals to match actual revenue where the contract allows it.
  • Modification: negotiating lower or less frequent payments.
  • Consolidation: combining several advances into one payment. Our guide to MCA consolidation walks through how that works.
  • Settlement: resolving the balance for less than the full amount, usually negotiated after payment trouble. See how restructuring compares with settlement.

State law can matter. In a 2023 settlement, the New Jersey Attorney General reached a consent order with MCA providers. It limits when a guarantor’s personal assets can be reached, and it requires reconciliation requests to consider the whole life of the advance. That order applies to the parties in that case, so it is not a nationwide rule. Your contract and state law decide your rights, and an attorney can read them against your situation.

If withdrawals now exceed what your sales can carry, start with MCA payments higher than revenue. For contract review and preparation, see our MCA debt restructuring guide, and if you have already missed payments, the MCA default guide explains what usually comes next.

Our perspective

Most owners we hear from wait too long. They wait because the first call feels like admitting failure, and by the time they reach out, several payments are already behind.

We see restructuring differently. It is a normal business tool, and it works best when the owner treats it as a planning exercise: what can the business really pay each week, and which terms make that possible?

That is why we built a quick, no-obligation assessment. We look at your situation, then connect you with independent providers who handle restructuring, consolidation or settlement. Because more than one provider may be a fit, the options can be matched to your circumstances instead of forced into a single template.

We cannot promise any outcome, and every provider makes its own decisions. What we can do is help you understand your choices before you commit to anything.

Danny

Next step: see which options fit your business

If your payments are straining cash flow, you do not need to settle on a path before you reach out. Our MCA restructuring page explains how payment terms can be adjusted, and you can submit a free, no-obligation inquiry through MCA Payment Options. We then connect you with independent providers whose services fit your business. Results depend on your contracts, your finances and the provider.

FAQ

Is commercial loan restructuring the same as refinancing?

No. Restructuring changes the terms of the loan you already have, while refinancing replaces it with a new loan. Refinancing needs a new approval. Restructuring needs your current lender to agree.

Will restructuring hurt my credit?

It can affect how you are viewed. Credit bureaus and commercial reporting may label a loan as restructured or modified, and that can influence future borrowing terms. Ask your lender how it will report the change before you sign.

When should I ask for a restructuring?

As early as you can, ideally before you miss a payment. Lenders tend to be more open when the account is current and you arrive with a clear plan. Waiting until default narrows the options.

What should I bring to the conversation?

Bring an explanation of what caused the shortfall, three to six months of cash flow projections, recent financial statements and a plan showing you can meet the new payment. Having an accountant prepare the figures makes the package easier for a lender to trust.

Can I restructure a merchant cash advance?

Often there are options, such as reconciliation, modification, consolidation or settlement, depending on your contract and the funder. Outcomes vary by provider and circumstances. A no-obligation inquiry can show which routes may apply to you.

M
Merchantprogramsolutions
Discuss Your MCA Payment Options
Share your situation for a quick, no-obligation assessment and a connection to independent providers offering restructuring options tailored to your business.
daniel@merchantprogramsolutions.com

Sources

Related reading

Merchant Program Solutions is not a lender, law firm, debt settlement provider, financial adviser, or government agency. Information on this page is general and should not replace legal, financial, tax, or accounting advice. Every business situation is different.